Mexico - Upton Towans

Yellow Graphic of a family of three walking. A man, woman and a child.
Row wavy Shape Decorative svg added to bottom

Mexico Towans and Upton Towans (Cornish: Tewyn, meaning ‘sand dune’) are a part of the wider Towans associated with St Ives Bay. The series of individually named Towans indicate that the sands associated with the location have long been part of the sites rich heritage. This can be appreciated when looking at the expanse of sand to both the east and west of the location. 

Both Upton and Mexico Towans are north-west facing sites, and a small portion of an extensive beach that stretches for almost 7 kilometres from Carrack Gladden to the west and Godrevy Point to the north. As the tide drops from high water, all the ‘Towans’ join up to provide an impressive stretch of sand. The sediments associated with the gently sloping shoreline of Mexico and Upton Towans are soft, medium grained with a high shell content. The uppershore of the beach is dominated by the high climbing extensive dunes, which are designated for a diversity of ecological reasons.  

The locations are considered as more of a rural beach environment, but their proximity to the town of Hayle and holiday parks within the wider Towans, means they can become seasonally quite busy. 

Yellow Graphic of a family of three walking. A man, woman and a child.
Yellow Graphic of two children walking. A boy and girl.

Coastal Change

The coastline of Cornwall is an ever-changing environment. It is energetic, dynamic, never still and changes with each wave and each tidal cycle. Some of the changes we see are gradual and barely noticeable, whilst others, such as rockfalls, happen suddenly and often shockingly.  

From one visit to the next it can sometimes be difficult to see how a beach and dune system has changed, but information has been collected, and is being collected through the Making Space for Sand project, to help us better understand how the coastline is changing. The purpose of this section of the website is to understand each location has changed over time, how it could change in the future and understand the policies that influence how we can respond to these changes.  

Shoreline Management Plans (SMP)

The Shoreline Management Plan (SMP) is a strategic planning and management assessment tool that helps identify and measure the risk associated coastal erosion and coastal flooding. The document makes a number of policy recommendations over short, medium and long term timeframes setting out a strategic approach to managing the built, natural and historic environments associated with the coastline. Within SMP there are four policy approaches which have been assigned to stretches of coastlines. The four policies are: No Active Intervention (NAI), Hold The Line (HTL), Managed Realignment (MR), and Advance The Line (ATL).  

© Crown copyright and database rights 2026 Ordnance Survey AC0000817921.

Mexico and Upton Towans sit within Policy Development Zone 10 (PDZ10), in Management Area 28 (MA28), within Policy Unit (PU) 28.2. The policy recommendations for this policy unit are detailed in the table below and the SMP can be accessed through the Cornwall Council website.

Use your touchscreen
to scroll the below table

Policy Unit SMP2 Policy Plan
2025 2055 2105 Rationale
28.1 Black Cliff

Main Policy

Sub Policy

 

 

NAI

DnD

 

NAI

DnD

 

NAI

DnD

Erosion and flood risk mapping indicates very low risk (and no assets at risk) so no intervention required. NAI is the preferred approach.  Allow natural coastal evolution to support conservation and local designations.

 

28.2 Mexico Towans to Gwithian Towans

Main Policy

Sub Policy

 

 

 

MR

NF

 

 

MR

NF

 

 

MR

NF

A managed realignment approach is preferred to accommodate the natural variability of this area. This would allow priority to be given to enhancement of the natural dune system as a UK priority BAP Habitat.

The area is under pressure from existing development and infrastructure of the holiday park behind the dunes. Number of blow outs along the frontage associated with access points to the holiday parks.  Loss of dune frontage expected in response to sea level rise, but it expected that there are sufficient sediment sources present to prevent significant dune roll back in the short to medium term.

 

Key Main Policy: HTL - Hold the Line, A - Advance the Line, NAI – No Active Intervention MR – Managed Realignment

Sub Policy: DnD – Do not Defend, NF – Natural Features

Yellow background graphic
Graphic of a yellow beach plant

© Crown copyright and database rights 2026 Ordnance Survey AC0000817921.

This mapping provides a baseline of coastal erosion for the coastline of England. The national coastal erosion risk map (NCERM) shows the areas at risk of coastal erosion until 2105. Predicting the exact position of an eroding shoreline over time is difficult. The influence of sea level rise on erosion rates in the longer term is also uncertain. The rate of erosion can vary depending on the geology and the natural processes at the coast. Hard rocks are worn away slower than softer material such as sand. This means erosion may not be the same along a stretch of coast.

Erosion risk zones displayed on the map include the area between the backshore feature (such as a cliff) and the Mean High Water Spring (MHWS) tidal position. These are shown for three climate change scenarios:

  • Present Day (2020) –uses historical erosion rates to provide future projections without calculating any additional impacts of climate change and rising sea levels. Beige layer
  • Climate Change Higher Central –uses sea level rise data from 70th percentile (UK Climate Projections 2018 (UKCP18) Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP)8.5 climate projection. Light purple layer
  • Climate Change Upper End –uses sea level rise data from 95th percentile UKCP18 Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP) 8.5 climate projection. Dark purple layer

What does this mean? Using the Climate Change Upper end as an example, it means that   95% of the possible scenarios fall below this level, while 5% fall above it. The RCP 8.5 value is a scenario used in climate modelling that considers the continued growth and production of greenhouse gas emissions. When planning for coastal change these worst-case scenarios, through more precautionary, help ensure that coastal management is, in the longer term, more resilient.

Unless otherwise stated, the erosion risk zones are based on the scenario that the Shoreline Management Plan (SMP) policy for the area has been delivered. A change in the policy, or the ability to deliver the policy intent, may affect the erosion projections.

The map provides the best estimate of coastal erosion risk at a national scale. It uses the best available national and local data along with methods which can be applied at a national scale. The erosion projections associated with NCERM are intended for guidance and cannot provide details for individual properties.  The NCERM data considers the predominant risk at the coast and frontages considered to be more at risk from flood risk or areas of complex cliff are not always included.

Click on the link below to access the Cornwall Council NCERM Mapping site, read the about section then click on layers - Shoreline Management Plan - NCERM SMP 2105.

Graphic of a yellow beach plant

3D Modelling of Sea Level Rise

Mexico-Upton Towans Sea Level Rise

The National Coastal Erosion Risk Map (NCERM) helps to provide a risk projection of how the coast may change over time. However, it doesn’t consider areas with high flood risk or predict the sea’s future position. To address this, the MS4S project has created 3D visuals that combine sea level rise and coastal change for flood-prone areas.  They match Shoreline Management Plan (SMP) timeframes in three stages: present day, 2055, and 2105.

The visuals use the Climate Change Higher Central scenario, shown in the NCERM section above, and assumes SMP policies haven’t been implemented, leaving erosion unchecked. Where the policy is ‘Hold the Line’ and defences have not been maintained or replaced, they show faster change after defences fail, a process known as coastal catch-up. Where there are gaps in the NCERM data, the Bruun modelling below, modelled by the University of Plymouth, provides guidance.

The animation shows the approximate Mean High Water levels and does not show higher or (Spring tides) or low (Neap tides) referencing tidal gauge data from Plymouth, Newlyn, and Padstow. Sea level projections use the Climate Change Higher Central scenario for Mean High Water levels in three, slightly different to the SMP above, epoch stages: 2025, 2075, and 2125.  They give an easy-to-understand view of how the coast might look in the future. However, they are for guidance only and recognise that there are uncertainties associated with erosion and sea level rise.

Yellow Graphic of a beach plant.

Historical Images of the Towans

Historical photographs provide a powerful insight into how the Cornish coastline has changed within the past Century. The Making Space for Sand project are working in collaboration with the Francis Frith collection and have been given permission to share historical images on a number of beaches considered within the project.     

In looking back, we can better understand how the coastline has changed, helping us understand not only how the coastal fringe has developed but also the potential future changes that we my observe. When this is considered alongside forecasts of coastal erosion and sea level rise it will help enable us to better adapt to our changing coastline. 

The Towans, c1955. Image courtesy of the Francis Frith collection.

CoastSnap

CoastSnap, is an innovative community science project, originally started in 2017 in Australia.  It enables communities to take part in coastal science by capturing and sharing images of their local beaches using specially designed phone cradles. From these images, we can monitor coastal change, beach change and the impacts of climate change on the region’s coastlines.

On behalf of MS4S, project partner South West Coastal Monitoring have installed 23 CoastSnap stations at strategic locations around the coast including this location. We have collated some of the images taken at this location and overlaid them, so you are able to see the series of changes that have taken place over time in the animation below.

For more information on CoastSnap and how to participate please go to our CoastSnap page or visit: southwest.coastalmonitoring.org/coastsnap-home/

Mexico_Towans CoastSnap
White wave graphic

Modelling Coastal Change

Using data that has already been collected, combined with data collected through the Making Space for Sand project, a series of models will be carried out at each location. This will help us better understand how each location may respond to sea level rise and gain a deeper understanding of how coastal sediments move and behave. 

The complexity of the modelling, and the data collection that helps inform it, means that modelling outputs will not be the same on all sites. Some locations will be more thoroughly investigated to understand more complex issues and provide data that can be more widely applied to other sites with similar characteristics.   

As the project develops this section of the website will expand, sharing new reports and coastal change projections when they are produced.  

Beach Report

The South West Coastal Monitoring (SWCM) programme have routinely been collecting data about the Cornish coastline since 2006. The aim of the data is to better understand changes observed on the coastline to help enable coastal managers to plan for future coastal change.

Using several years of information, SWCM have created a beach report for each MS4S site, including one for Mexico/Upton Towans. The purpose of this report is to help the reader better understand the range of surveys completed on Mexico/Upton Towans and see the changes recorded. Some of the changes observed are gradual, whilst others, such as those associated with serve storm conditions, are more sudden and dramatic.

18 Mexico Towans LiDAR Difference Model

The picture above represents a combination of LiDAR data captured from c2008 - 2025 and the shading illustrates how sand (sediment) has been gained and lost over this period of time.  The areas shaded blue are areas where sand has built up (increase in sediment) and areas shaded red show where sand has been lost (erosion of sediment). The deeper the shade of red or blue, the greater the level or erosion or accumulation.

SWCM provide an interactive map viewer on their website that allows users to explore and view the various data types they collect. If you want to learn more about this location, or other beaches in the south west, please visit their Map Viewer webpage.

Bruun Rule

Future change in the dune toe position, at this location, has been projected using either Bruun rule or estimated based on observed trends. The Bruun rule is a mathematical model to help us predict how our beaches will change with sea level rise. It is based on the theory that beaches will shift upwards and landwards in order to ‘keep up’ with sea level rise.  The Bruun rule doesn’t consider all variables so there is a degree of uncertainty with these projections, however, they represent a first-stage assessment of future dune behaviour in Cornwall.

MexicoTowans

On Mexico - Upton Towans sediment is eroding from the uppershore and/or dune toe and there is an increase in the volume of sediment in this area, which is potential evidence of coastal rollback. With sea level rise the estimated rate of retreat at the location is 13m (0.17m per year) by 2100. For more information please visit the Bruun Rule section on the Data Modelling webpage.

The visual presented above displays a number of things. The areas shaded blue are areas where surveys identify an increase in elevation (accumulation of sediment) and areas shaded red a decrease in elevation (erosion of sediment). The deeper the shade of red or blue, the greater the level or erosion or accumulation. The solid black line marks the edge of the dune toe and/or the top of the beach. The solid green line marks the projected rate of erosion by 2100, by using the Bruun Rule. This assumes the highest baseline climate change scenario where emissions continue to rise throughout the twenty-first century, Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP 8.5). The faint green line either side of the solid green line visualises the 90% confidence interval for the projection, indicating how the situation could be better or worse than projected.

Graphic of a yellow beach plant

Tromino

Tromino surveys help scientists find out how much sand is stored beneath a beach without digging. A small device called a Tromino measures tiny natural vibrations in the ground caused by waves, wind, and traffic. Different materials such as sand, gravel, clay, and rock vibrate in different ways, allowing scientists to estimate what lies below the surface and how deep it is.

The results are used to create underground maps of beaches, showing where sand layers end and rock layers begin. This helps scientists understand how beaches may change in the future as sea levels rise and storms become more frequent. The information is also used in computer models to support coastal management and help protect coastlines.

Please find below the report for this location:

18 Mexico Towans_Page_1
Tromino Output Report from the University of Plymouth
18 Mexico Towans_Page_2
Tromino Output Report from the University of Plymouth

To interpret Tromino data, read the graph from left to right, moving from the dunes towards the lower beach. The green line shows the beach surface, while dashed lines represent boundaries between different underground materials, such as sand, gravel, or bedrock. The dashed yellow line represents the Mean Sea Level (MSL) which is the average height of the sea surface used to measure elevation.

Areas coloured red and yellow indicate stronger changes between layers and help identify where these boundaries are located. Blue and green colours show weaker changes. The deeper dashed black line usually represents the base of the sediment or possible bedrock, while dashed blue lines show shallower sediment layers. By looking at the depth and position of these layers, scientists can estimate sediment thickness across the beach.

South West Coastal Monitoring Dashboard

The South West Coastal Monitoring Dashboard is a new, interactive and intuitive tool which you can use to analyse the latest and historic topographic data for all beaches in the South West.

The Dashboard's main purpose is analyse how beaches across the South West have changed historically over the last 18 years. It provides an overview of change of the South West but also allows you to investigate in detail, certain beach profiles for a specific survey date at a site of interest. The Dashboard displays the following six interactive features:

  • Map Overview - Provides a regional overview of historic and yearly change for each survey unit.
  • Combined Profile Area Chart (CPA m²) - Represents the combined profile area trend in cross-sectional area (CSA m²) for each survey unit.
  • Profile Cross-Sectional Area Chart - Provides a visual representation of the beach profile cross-sectional area (CSA m²) change.
  • Box Plot - Displays the latest cross-sectional area (CSA m²) min, max, upper and lower quartile ranges for all profiles in the survey unit.
  • Cross-Sectional Area Change Table - Displays cross-sectional area (CSA m²) and percentage change values for each beach profile.
  • Survey Report Generator - Automatically generates a topographic survey report for a survey unit of choice.

To access the South West Coastal Monitoring Dashboard please click on the button below:

Blue wave graphic
Yellow Graphic of a beach plant.

Beach and Dune Ecology

Beaches and dunes represent an important transition between the marine environment and the terrestrial environment. This transition creates a range of special habitats and exposes interesting features, which that can result in these spaces being highly designated and protected. 

At Mexico-Upton Towans a dune habitat survey has been completed to help better understand the condition of the dune system. The survey identifies challenges that impact on the quality of the dune system as well highlighting rare and interesting finds made on it. In some instances the surveys also consider data collected from habitat surveys carried out in 2005. Where this has been possible it enables us to understand how the dunes have changed over a relatively short period of time.

Across the site 203ha of vegetated habitat was mapped. The range of different habitats mapped on the Towans, included open dunes (7%), shifting dune (8%), dune grassland (73%), dense scrub (12%) and mixed scrub (4%). Other habitats types, including reedbed, swamps, grassland, open water, maritime cliff, dune slack and woodland all cover a small percentage of the dune system surveyed.

The Towans represent an extensive and complex dune system with a mosaic of habitats. The system is in fair-moderate condition, which is an achievement given the size of the dunes.  Throughout the survey a diverse range of threatened, vulnerable, national scares, nationally rare and notable plant species were observed across the habitats associated with the Towans.

Some areas of the dune system suffer from heavy disturbance from human activities. The result of this is that some habitat types have become dispersed and fragmented. Invasive species are well established and locally frequent within some areas of shifting dune. The survey identified well established areas of Japanese rose, red valerian, buddleia, sea buckthorn, montbretia, New Zealand flax and cotoneaster species. Though proportion of scrub is low, it represents large areas. If unmanaged its spread can negatively impact on the biodiversity have adjacent high value habitats.

Image shows Prickly Saltwort

prickly saltwort
prickly saltwort

Historic Comparison

A Habitat Assessment of the site was undertaken in 2006. When comparing this to the 2023 survey, it can be seen that there has been a 64% reduction of dune habitat. This is partially attributed to scrub encroachment and erosion of the dune. Areas bordering some carparks which were formerly occupied by dune and scrub habitats, have now transitioned to poor quality neutral grassland. The comparison also suggests that where scrub has been cleared the habitat that has established has been species poor grassland.

Japanese rose (Rosa rugosa)
Japanese rose (Rosa rugosa)

From a Biodiversity Net Gain perspective, key opportunities for enhancement at the Towans is in the management of scrub within the dune. Although it’s part of the successional process of dunes, the creation of clearing and glades would create a richer patchwork of habitats. Throughout the dunes and within the scrub invasive and non-native have established and are spreading. Removal of these species is recommended to limit their future spreading. A challenge with this is in the scale and breadth of the response. The dunes are vast and owned/managed by a range of stakeholders who need to coordinate their response to avoid further habitat degradation and fragmentation.

Image shows Japanese Rose which is a non-native species

Row concave Shape Decorative svg added to bottom
Yellow Marram Grass Graphic

Designations

Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI)

A Site of Special Scientific Interest or SSSI is a statutory conservation designation notified by Natural England denoting protection for biological and/or geological characteristics. The natural wildlife and geological features of SSSI’s are considered to be irreplaceable parts of the national heritage. These are protected in order to preserve their importance, and to prevent damage and development. 

Image of the view across the Towans

Gwithian to Mexico Towans SSSI

The Gwithian to Mexico Towans SSSI covers and area of 371.1 hectares. Gwithian to Mexico Towans constitutes the second largest dune system in Cornwall, stretching for approximately 3km. This exposed, dynamic dune system is subject to the full force of Atlantic gales, resulting in several large blow-outs along the seaward margin. This complex and extensive dune system supports a rich and diverse flora.

Graphic of a yellow beach plant

Beach Dune Management Plan

Many of the sand dunes and beaches around Cornwall’s coast are experiencing net erosion and sediment loss. This is due, in part, to lack of new sediment input to the shoreline system and rising sea levels. This is a pressing concern as these environments provide protection against the risk of coastal flooding, provide important habitats that cannot be easily recreated elsewhere if lost and help support the regions thriving tourism industry. It is therefore vital that the sand dunes and beaches around Cornwall’s coast are managed in a more sustainable way that balances the combined functions of beach-dune system. 

The Making Space for Sand project hope to develop a number of Beach Dune Management Plans, to complement those that have already been developed by Cornwall Council. It is anticipated that a BDMP will be developed for this location. The aim of the BDMP’s will be to:  

  • Identify the best day-to-day management approach in terms of monitoring and intervention for the beach and dune system. 
  • Provide a longer-term approach to beach and dune management based upon an up-to-date understanding of habitat condition, coastal processes at the site, as well as predictions of future coastal evolution. 

If you are interested in providing information and data or want to share you knowledge of changes observed on a site where a beach dune management plan is being considered please make contact with the Making Space for Sand project using the email provided at the bottom of this page or on the Community Engagement page.  

Sign up to Making Space for Sand

If you would like to get involved in helping to make dunes more resilient and biodiverse, want to help develop coastal adaptation and emergency plans or just want to know more about what the project is learning about coastal change, please click here:

Yellow Graphic of a beach plant.
Yellow Graphic of a beach plant.